Battle of Blue Water Creek, 9/2-3/1885

Lt. William S. Harney Attacks Brule Village--Harney Massacre

Jul 5, 2008 Jeannie Delahunt

Lt. Harney sought to punish the responsible Brule Sioux for the massacre of Lt. John Grattan's command. With 600 men he surrounded and ambushed the Sioux camp of 250.

Messengers alerted the Brule Sioux that many soldiers were traveling towards their camp situated near Blue Water Creek, Nebraska. Little Thunder, the chief of this band was informed that, if he wanted peace, he must relocate his village closer to Fort Laramie.

Decision Time

A massive buffalo hunt had just been completed by the warriors of Little Thunder's village. The women were busy cutting and drying the meat, curing the hides, as well as a number of associated tasks.

The messages troubled Little Thunder. After the Grattan Massacre, he had worked dilligently, persuading the young warriors that continued bloodshed would only boomerange back at them. Yes, he wanted peace. After council with other members of his village, it was decided that they would remain a few more days, until the work was completed, then, they would move completely out of the area where there were no soldiers or emigrants to contend with.

Harney's Strategy

During the night one of Harney's scouts, familiar with the Brule Sioux encampments, located Little Thunder's village. He led the horse soldiers above this location to cut off any means of escape:

The horse soldiers crossed the high prarie above the creek and hid in a gully to wait for the daylight attack while the walking soldiers moved up from the Platte towards the sleeping village.

The Negotiation Ruse and Attack

Flying white flags, unarmed, Little Thunder and three of the chiefs rode out to meet with Lt. Harney. Harney's soldiers (unkown to the chiefs) surrounded their village during the negotiations.

Harney demanded Little Thunder transfer to him the warriors responsible for the Grattan Massacre. Little Thunder tried to explain that there had been many Sioux involved in that gunfire, some of them visiting from other camps, other Sioux tribes. They were all mixed up, and those of the Minneconjous Sioux who were involved no longer resided in the area. Harney refused to listen.

LIttle Thunder, fearing the worst, returned to his village to instruct his people to prepare for a fight. To his surprise the village was already surrounded. When the soldiers saw him they fired. People scattered, some into surrounding caves, but the wagon-guns with howitzers shot into them.

While the batte was still raging, Curly, later known as Crazy Horse, rode upon the scene. Searching for survivors amongst the dead, he found a Cheyenne woman crouching near one of the bullet riddled caves, clutching a newborn baby. Her slightly older son and husband were dead. Curly found a travois to transport the woman and her baby to his village.

Brule Sioux Surrender

Little Thunder survived. To save the remaining survivors, three of his chiefs decided they would surrender themselves in lieu of the warriors Harney demanded. Members from their families had been taken captive--better to live or die with them then live free with broken hearts.

Once the chiefs arrived at Fort Laramie they were imprisoned. They and all the captives taken during the battle were led away. Where? The Sioux didn't know. Curly watched as they were led away on The Holy Road (Oregon Trail) and not seen again.

Source

Mari Sandoz, Crazy Horse Strange Man of the Oglalas, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln and London, 1992, pgs. 63-85.

The copyright of the article Battle of Blue Water Creek, 9/2-3/1885 in Native American/First Nations History is owned by Jeannie Delahunt. Permission to republish Battle of Blue Water Creek, 9/2-3/1885 in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
Calvary and Indians, Public Domain Calvary and Indians
Spotted Tail, Brule Chief, far left, Public Domain Spotted Tail, Brule Chief, far left
 
What do you think about this article?

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
post your comment
What is 1+10?

Comments

Nov 19, 2008 6:51 AM
Guest :
This article is extravagant, but I do not agree with the preposition of the whites. They mistreated most if not all of the Lakota. Their power is no longer needed today!
Nov 19, 2008 2:00 PM
Jeannie Delahunt :
This article was written on the heels of the one I did about Crazy Horse. What I was struck with, was the fact that, fear caused people to act irrationally, selfishly. Though we can't change the past, we can create a different present and future by the lessons learned in the past.

I believe we owe it to our children to learn from the past so that their future will be better--so history will not repeat itself.
Jul 24, 2009 11:24 PM
Guest :
"What I was struck with, was the fact that, fear caused people to act irrationally, selfishly. Though we can't change the past, we can create a different present and future by the lessons learned in the past."
------
An apt and fair enough point when taken in context with the time and continuing expansion and resistance being offered by all concerned.
However you are incorrect in assigning Harney the rank of LT at the time of this particular engagement.


Below is a link that examines this illustrious soldier and you might be interested in knowing, if you peruse his correspondence and varying bios; he was not the stereotypical 'Indian hater' that is often mistakenly ascribed to officers and soldiers during the expansion years of the American west.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~harney2/General/militar y.htm
You might in particular find this quote, lifted from the ascribed link, informative:
" After his death the Sioux changed his name from Man-who-runs-like-the-Deer to one of which he would have been very proud, "Man-who-always-kept-his-word"."

sincerly

LW Jensen
Captain (F)
5th US Cavalry
Jul 27, 2009 7:45 AM
Jeannie Delahunt :
Thank you Captain Jensen for your comment and information. I will do some additional research. As far as the Lt. title given to Harney, that was according to one of the sources. If it is incorrect, I will change it - thank you for pointing it out.

I will happily investigate the site you have given. And since I strive to be as objective as is humanly possible, I am always open to additional information.
Oct 8, 2009 3:15 PM
Guest :
A friend of mine and I just returned from hiking the area of the blue creek massacre, having permission from the rancher who now owns the land. The stories I have read stated that the indians fled to a cave to hide from the murderous soldiers. I found only one spot, which was not a cave, east of blue creek. Are there any maps available or GPS coordinates of the exact locations of the two camps? We believe we found the area of the two campsites, although the caves are another story. thanks
Oct 8, 2009 3:56 PM
Jeannie Delahunt :
I am unaware of exact coordinates. I'm not sure how one would go about finding out. I'll have to think on it.

I think it is good, sometimes to visit sites where tragedy has occurred. There is a holiness/sacredness about them. It doesn't matter what race we belong to, we are all humans in the end, capable of feeling great pain and joy. Precious is life!

I believe, if we all honored and lifted one another up, tragedy would end. If you are able to find the location, please say a prayer for me that nothing similar on US soil will ever happen again. Blessings!
6 Comments